What’s Fueled the Value Recovery?
Several catalysts helped awaken value stocks, which began the year with exceptionally cheap valuations: First, companies in the value universe generally delivered earnings growth above expectation. Second, key value-oriented industries performed especially well, including European banks—as a steep yield curve buoyed profitability—and defense. Third, Asian corporate governance reforms are gaining traction.
In Europe, regional defense spending has increased amid heightened geopolitical tensions related to the Russia-Ukraine war and uncertainty over the US defense umbrella. EU defense spending rose by 19% in 2024 to €343 billion, or 1.9% of GDP, according to the European Council. The North Atlantic Treaty Organization is pressing its members to allocate at least 3% of GDP for defense budgets over the coming years, which could add another €220 billion a year to European military spending.
That translates to a big business boost for large, regional defense contractors, which can support stable cash flows and dividend payouts. These companies are prominent members of the value cohort.
Asia’s Corporate Governance Catalyst
Meanwhile, a new culture of corporate governance reform is taking root across Asia. China, South Korea and Japan are pushing reforms to boost shareholder value. In Japan, regulators are encouraging companies to reduce cross-shareholdings and deploy hoarded cash to boost operating leverage and streamline balance sheets. These moves could prompt a recovery in select Japanese companies with attractive valuations and a clear path to improve profitability.
China, too, is pressing companies to improve governance via the 2024 nine-point guidelines. These moves have helped lift profitability, dividends and buybacks to record highs. South Korean initiatives are in full swing through the “value up” program, which aims to incentivize improved capital management and operating performance. The goal: to boost valuations in a South Korean market that has had an exceptionally high proportion of cheaply valued stocks for years.
Is There More Room to Run?
After such a strong year, it’s natural for investors to question the staying power of non-US value stocks. We think there are good reasons to believe that the trend can continue.
First, the catalysts above are long-term trends that should continue to evolve. Defense spending in Europe is being driven by seismic geopolitical shifts that aren’t going away. Corporate governance reform is a multi-year process; while policy-driven changes can be erratic, we expect developments in Asia to create a virtuous circle, as more companies discover the benefits of cleaning up their businesses for shareholders.
Second, we’re seeing signs of other value-friendly themes developing. Examples include rising demand for commercial aircraft, a recovery in depressed agricultural commodity prices and the recovery of healthcare R&D spending from post-pandemic pressures. These trends support select opportunities in value-oriented companies with healthier businesses than perceived.
Third, new forces could propel value market segments that haven’t yet rebounded. For example, a continued weakening of the US dollar could support emerging-market stocks, which have not yet fully participated in the value rally.
Valuations Are Still Attractive
Even after this year’s rebound, ex-US value stocks still offer attractive discounts for investors by several measures. The MSCI EAFE Value’s price-to-forward-earnings ratio trades at a discount of 43% to growth stocks and 21% to the broader market (Display).